✦ Official Example
Review Complete
📋 Request
Negotiating Your First Freelance Design Contracts — Is the AI's Advice Practical for Real Client Rel
I'm a UX designer going fully freelance for the first time. I asked an AI for contract and negotiation advice. The advice felt generic. I want to understand how professional freelancers actually handle retainer requests and scope management in real client relationships, and how to use copyright law as a pricing mechanism.
General200 pts
Overall Assessment
The AI's guidance is accurate and practical throughout. The retainer framing, scope definition approach, feedback abandonment clause, and copyright tiered licensing structure are all correct and actionable. The kill fee and project pause clause question is the right follow-up for anyone working with larger organizational clients.
Key Findings
✅ What's accurate: - The retainer framing ("I start work after the contract is signed and the retainer is confirmed") is correct and effective - Scope definition over revision counting is the right approach and the feedback abandonment clause is an important addition - The copyright tiered licensing structure and the client framing language are accurate and practically effective ❌ What's inaccurate or misleading: - No significant inaccuracies — the AI's guidance is accurate throughout ⚠️ What's missing or overlooked: - Kill fee and project pause clauses are particularly important for larger organizational clients where internal approval delays, budget freezes, and organizational changes mid-project are common — the AI's guidance didn't cover these - Specifying who has authority to pause or cancel the project prevents situations where a project is effectively abandoned by one team while another claims it's still active
Action Items
1. Add milestone payment structure to all contracts: 50% at contract signature, 30% at primary intermediate deliverable, 20% at final delivery — define what constitutes each phase and its value weight before work begins 2. Add a project pause clause: "If the project is paused for more than 30 days due to client unavailability or internal delays, a restart fee of 20% of the remaining project value applies upon resumption" 3. Add a kill fee clause: "In the event of client-initiated termination, payment is due for all completed phases at the phase rates specified above, payable within 14 days of termination notice" 4. For larger organizational clients, specify in writing who has authority to pause or cancel the project — this prevents abandonment-by-ambiguity situations
Additional Resources
- AIGA Design Business and Ethics guide: https://www.aiga.org/design-business-and-ethics - Bonterms standard services contract templates: https://bonterms.com - Freelancers Union contract resources: https://www.freelancersunion.org/resources/contracts